Discussion:Make a Milkshake Without Ice Cream

IF you sahake it a little longer it will be ice cream

i used a garbage bage (: yay :)

I thought you said without milk .

The title specifically says how to make a milkshake WITHOUT MILK (or icecream)

yeah i think a title change is in order, or a rewrite

support title change. should say "how to make a vanilla milkshake without ice-cream"

The title says "without milk". The ingredients say "Milk".

whoever wrote this is stupid. The title says NO MILK. Your first ingrediant is MILK. idiot. Fix the title!

Maybe the title could say "without ice and sugar" also

title = fail

use rock salt on the ice in the big bag and itll come out actual ice cream..oh and the title is misleading

I was expecting an article on milkshake without either milk or ice cream. Instead I got and article on how to prepare a milkshake with milk and without a blender....

The blinder option doesnt really work all that well i did everything they said too and it tasted disgusting... They should take that option off the site

This article doesn't mention the measurement of milk. If it's 2 cups of milk, 1 teaspoon of sugar is fine. But what if you're using less than 2 cups, or 4+ cups? This is a good base for milkshakes, but you still need something to make it creamy, which is why ice cream is used normally. Vanilla extract isn't best. If you do use it, don't put more than just a couple drops. You're better off using fruit. Without milk, this would be a smoothie.

this was completely disgusting thank alot

This recipe is not very useful!

I loved it! Tried the bag method! Be careful not to put too much salt in, though! Try 2-3 tbs of cocoa powder for a chocolate one!